Skip to main content

IAA and Trades Support Rescission of Pay to Play Rule

November 9, 2026


Download PDF

Ms. Vanessa Countryman
Secretary
Securities and Exchange Commission
100 F Street NE
Washington, DC 20549-1091

Re: Political Contributions by Certain Investment Advisers; Release No. IA-6994; File No. S7-2026-31

 

Dear Ms. Countryman:

We the undersigned trade and other associations (Associations) write to express our support for the Securities and Exchange Commission’s (the Commission or SEC) proposal to rescind Rule 206(4)-5 under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940, as amended (the Advisers Act), commonly known as the “Political Contribution Rule” or “Pay-to-Play Rule” (the Rule), together with its corresponding recordkeeping requirements under Rule 204-2.[1] This letter represents the consensus view of the undersigned, all of whom have found, whether through experience with the administration of the Rule or consideration of its impact on the political process, that it is a flawed regulation imposing substantial burdens on investors, investment advisers, and advisory personnel without a commensurate benefit.

We also emphasize, as noted below, that if the SEC decides to rescind the Rule, the Commission will retain authority under Section 206(4) of the Advisers Act and other existing Federal securities laws to bring enforcement actions for fraud and breach of fiduciary duty where contributions are made with an intent to influence the award of government business. Advisers will also continue to be bound by their Advisers Act fiduciary duty, as well as the compliance rule and code of ethics rule, with respect to contributions. In addition, political contributions will remain governed by federal, state, and local campaign finance laws, and corrupt conduct will remain subject to federal, state, and local anti-fraud laws.

 

Executive Summary

The Associations support the rescission of the current Rule in its entirety—rather than targeted amendments—for the following reasons:

  • Unintended consequences, such as advisers being unable to hire or promote talented candidates because of a past political contribution;
  • Restrictions on political speech resulting from the Rule that raise serious First Amendment concerns;
  • The existence of other legal prohibitions better tailored to address the misuse of client assets to secure government business, including under the Advisers Act’s fiduciary duty, compliance rule, and code of ethics rule;
  • The range of state and local government contracting requirements applicable to advisers with public investors or clients;
  • The operational difficulties of administering the Rule, given its strict liability framework; and
  • The significant compliance burdens that the Rule imposes on advisers of all sizes.

 

1. The Rule Produces Unintended Consequences for Hiring, Promotion, and Investors

Because the Rule looks back at contributions made before an individual became a “covered associate,” it can prevent an adviser from hiring or promoting the most qualified candidate solely because of a lawful contribution made months or years earlier, thereby chilling professional mobility both inside and outside of their firm. It can also distort adviser selection, since a client may lose access to its preferred adviser based on an employee’s past contribution rather than factors such as ability to execute the chosen investment strategy, past performance, or fees. The ultimate harm falls on public pension plans and other government investors, and their respective beneficiaries, denied access to the best available, most cost-effective advisory services.

 

2. The Rule’s Breadth Raises Serious First Amendment Concerns

Because even a modest lawful contribution can trigger a severe automatic penalty, many advisers feel compelled to prohibit employee political contributions altogether, even where little or no risk exists. This chilling effect reaches core political speech protected by the First Amendment and therefore raises serious constitutional concerns.[2]

 

3. Existing Legal Requirements Continue to Address Corruption Concerns

Rescinding the Rule will not leave pay-to-play practices unregulated. Advisers will remain subject to the Advisers Act’s fiduciary duty, compliance rule, and code of ethics rule—overlapping protections sufficient to safeguard investors without the Rule’s rigid, strict liability approach. The Commission will also retain authority under the federal securities laws to bring enforcement actions for fraud, breaches of fiduciary duty, and pay-to-play conduct. In addition, federal, state, and local laws that operate independently of the Rule will remain in effect.

 

4. The Rule’s Strict Liability Framework Creates Serious Operational Difficulties

The Rule requires no showing of intent or quid pro quo; any covered contribution automatically triggers a two-year compensation ban. This de facto strict liability standard means that a contribution of as little as $151 or $351 can disqualify an adviser from servicing a government client, regardless of the intent of the contributor. Further, the Rule’s use of vague terms, including “covered associate” and “official,” in defining the scope of the prohibition forces many advisers into overly conservative, blanket restrictions on employee political activity simply to manage risk of technical noncompliance. This rigid framework does not allow consideration of the facts and circumstances of a contribution and is ill-suited to the Rule’s anti-corruption goals.

 

5. The Rule Imposes Substantial Compliance Burdens

Advisers also face significant, ongoing compliance costs. For example, the Rule’s outdated, unchanged de minimis thresholds often conflict with state and local campaign finance limits, creating duplicative, overlapping obligations that are difficult to administer. In addition, advisers relying on the “returned contribution” exception, which is available only for contributions of $350 or less, must obtain a refund within 60 days—often impractical, since the adviser cannot direct the recipient campaign to respond to a refund request.

 

6. The Commission Should Rescind the Rule Rather Than Pursue Targeted Amendments

Given the range and severity of these issues, we support rescission over targeted amendments to discrete aspects of the Rule. Following rescission, advisers should remain free to design policies and procedures tailored to their own business models, risk profiles, and legal and regulatory obligations.

 

We appreciate the Commission’s attention to this issue and its efforts to eliminate a regulation that has long imposed disproportionate burdens on advisers, their employees, and the government clients and investors they serve. We urge the Commission to finalize the proposal and rescind the Rule.

***

Sincerely,

Alternative Investment Management Association|
American Free Enterprise Chamber of Commerce
American Securities Association
Finseca
Investment Company Institute
Investment Adviser Association
LSTA, Inc.
Managed Funds Association
Partnership for New York City
Small Business Investor Alliance
Securities Industry and Financial Markets Association
SIFMA AMG
U.S. Chamber of Commerce

 

cc:

Paul Atkins, Chairman
Mark T. Uyeda, Commissioner
Brian Daly, Director, Division of Investment Management
Sarah ten Siethoff, Associate Director, Division of Investment Management

 


[1] See Political Contributions by Certain Investment Advisers, 91 Fed. Reg. 57698 (Sept. 10, 2026), available at https://www.sec.gov/files/rules/proposed/2026/ia-6994.pdf (the “Proposal”).

[2] Since the Rule’s adoption in 2010, the Supreme Court has applied more rigorous First Amendment scrutiny to restrictions on political contributions and speech, requiring stronger justification for them. See McCutcheon v. FEC, 572 U.S. 185 (2014) and FEC v. Ted Cruz for Senate, 596 U.S. 289 (2022).

Tags: Pay to Play

You are now leaving Investment Adviser Association

The IAA provides links to web sites of other organizations in order to provide visitors with certain information. A link does not constitute an endorsement of content, viewpoint, policies, products or services of that web site. Once you link to another web site not maintained by the IAA, you are subject to the terms and conditions of that web site, including but not limited to its privacy policy.

You will be redirected to

Click the link above to continue or CANCEL

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.